2 weeks ago
12.1K
411
11
49
Caption: Touching a woman could break your wudu. The entire disagreement between the four madhabs traces back to a single Arabic word in Surah Al Maidah verse 6. Allah s… more Touching a woman could break your wudu. The entire disagreement between the four madhabs traces back to a single Arabic word in Surah Al Maidah verse 6. Allah says “aw lamastum al nisa” which translates roughly as “or you have touched women.” Four of the greatest legal minds in Islamic history looked at that exact same phrase and came to four completely different conclusions. That alone should tell you how deep and sophisticated Islamic scholarship really is. The Shafi’i madhab takes the most well known position on this. They interpreted “lamastum” as referring to direct physical touch. So any skin to skin contact with a non mahram woman breaks your wudu completely, regardless of intention, regardless of desire, regardless of whether it was accidental. And yes, this includes your wife, because your wife is not your mahram. This is why you will notice Muslims in Malaysia and Indonesia, where the Shafi’i madhab dominates, being very careful about physical contact before prayer. The Hanafi madhab sits at the complete opposite end. They interpreted “lamastum” as referring to sexual intercourse, not physical touch at all. So in the Hanafi position, touching a woman, any woman, under any circumstances, does not break your wudu. A handshake, an accidental brush, holding your wife’s hand, none of it affects your purity whatsoever. The Maliki madhab took a middle path. Touching a woman only breaks wudu if desire is present in that moment. A neutral, emotionless touch leaves your wudu completely intact. But here is where the Malikis get uniquely interesting — they also considered the fear of desire. Meaning if you touch a woman and you know yourself well enough that desire is likely to follow even if it hasn’t arrived yet, some Maliki scholars said that anticipation alone is enough to break your wudu. It is arguably the most psychologically nuanced ruling of all four madhabs. The Hanbali madhab is very similar to the Maliki position. Touch without desire does not break wudu. Touch with desire does. However the Hanbali scholars had a specific internal discussion about kissing your wife, with some scholars arguing that kissing carries a stronger case for breaking wudu than regular touch, even if desire is not consciously present, simply because of the nature of the act itself. less
Download Video Download Audio MP3 Download Cover Image